Fantastic idea Elena! If only Israel had thought of this earlier! Oh wait..

They gave up the Sinai to Egypt and now it is a hotbed of terrorism that destabilises both countries.

In 2005 they left Gaza, evacuated all the Jews from there. Left Gaza alone and it was a better place to live as a Palestinian than the West Bank. But Hamas did a coup, killed the Palestinian Authority workers there and fired 10,000 rockets at Israel in 2 years.

Every time Israel has given up land it has been met with more violence. So why Israel give up more?

As for your disgusting comment about Israel's creation- over half the Jews of Israel are from Arab countries and Iran, not Europe. Places they were second class citizens for a thousand years. Now they live in their ancestral homeland which always had a Jewish presence, near where their ancestors are buried, where they can practice their religion for those who are religious and they have no one above them, Christian or Muslim, telling what to do. Israel is highly flawed but it is the most successful self- determination of an indigenous people in the world today.

Would you say Ukraine should give up land for peace?